oldman wrote:I'm really not big on the high protein low carb diets.
As a health thing, they are unsustainable. Do it short term if you have to, but it isn't a lifestyle, and it isn't a healthy diet. Protein requirements for the average adult are quite minimal anyway, and pretty much all the good things your body needs are in vegies, which are carbs (and fibre).
Can't agree that the time of day for when you take in certain types of foods is relevant. It has repeatedly been shown to be inconsequential in lab tests, and I haven't seen any that support it.
As for the idea of reducing fat in certain spots of your body, I'm pretty sure that where your body deposits fat is entirely a product of your genetic disposition. You can reduce your overall fat levels, but your body will not take fat from a particular part of your body in preference to another, other than as it has been programmed by your genes.
There is no one diet fits all, they are all goal dependant. An endurance athlete is not going to be able to function on the cutting diet of a bodybuilder and vice versa. As far as the timing of different types of food is concerned it's also a by product of your goal, I have never looked up studies in relation to carb timing but conventional wisdom and my own personal experience tells me that when I want to lean up, not having carbs at night is a tried and tested way of getting where I want to go. BTW I don't count vegies in my carb intake, as I mentioned earlier a lot of them almost calorie negative. For dinner last night I had a roo steak and steamed brocolli.
If you really want to get technical, once you have established a maintenance calorie level for yourself you can manipulate the intake based upon your activity for the day. Say your normal maintenance calories are 2500 but you want to go surfing for 3 hours, you could quite happily add 300 cals of carbs into your first couple of meals without any negative impact. I didn't say anything about this prior cause ppl tend to take it as a get out jail free card, oh I'm going surfing so I can mung out on bacon and egg rolls and a large chips.
The average adult is overweight, should we compare ourselves to the lowest common denominator so we can feel better about ourselves? I would prefer to aim a little higher, to do that I need to train and therefore I have a higher protein requirement than the average person. Typically I try ti get around 1.5grams of protein per kilo of bodyweight. From memory the recommended dietary intake is .5grams per kilo. I may have excess protein but I would rather have excess to my requirements than be in the negative.
I'll leave it at that for now, might start turning ppl off trying if it looks to complicated but it's something I'm kinda interested in.